Club Name : DebunkingPseudoscience
Description : Do not make new posts just to advertise your site. If you are caught doing so you will be banned.
Reference Links
James Randi Educational Foundation
The Skeptics Society & Skeptic magazine
The Skeptic's Dictionary
Committee for the Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal
QuackWatch
Astrology and Science
Bad Astronomy
Crank dot Net
Insultingly Stupid Movie Physics
"Science Myths" in K-6 Textbooks and Popular culture
Pseudoscience - Wikipedia
Introduction
The standards for determining of any body of knowledge, methodology, or practice as nonscience vary, but often include lack of empirical evidence, unfalsifiability, or failure to comply with scientific method or apply a heuristic such as Occam's Razor. A number of attempts have been made to apply philosophical rigor to the notion with mixed results. These include Karl Popper's criterion of falsifiability and the historiographical approach of Imre Lakatos in his Methodology of Scientific Research Programmes. Other historians and philosophers of science (including Paul Feyerabend) have argued, from a sociology of knowledge perspective, that a clear philosophical distinction between science and pseudoscience is neither possible nor desirable.
The term "pseudoscience" often has negative connotations, implying generally that things so labeled are false and deceptive (though a strict interpretation of the term would not necessarily have it mean either). As such, those who are labelled as practicing or advocating a "pseudoscience" almost always reject this classification, and often the distinction itself.
Some critics of pseudoscience consider some or all forms of pseudoscience to be harmless entertainment. Others, such as Richard Dawkins, Mario Bunge and Carl Sagan, consider almost all forms of pseudoscience to be harmful, whether or not they result in immediate harm to their followers. These critics generally consider that advocacy of pseudoscience may occur for a number of reasons, ranging from simple naïveté about the nature of science and the scientific method, to deliberate deception for financial or political benefit.
The concept of pseudoscience as an antagonist to bona fide science appears to have emerged in the mid-19th century. The first recorded use of the word 'pseudo-science' appears to have been in 1844 in the Northern Journal of Medicine I. 387 "That opposite kind of innovation which pronounces what has been recognised as a branch of science, to have been a pseudo-science, composed merely of so-called facts, connected together by misapprehensions under the disguise of principles".
Classifying pseudoscience
Pseudoscience fails to meet the criteria met by science generally (including the scientific method), and can be identified by a combination of these characteristics:
by asserting claims or theories unconnected to previous experimental results;
by asserting claims which cannot be verified or falsified (claims that violate);
by asserting claims which contradict experimentally established results;
by failing to provide an experimental possibility of reproducible results;
by failing to submit results to peer review prior to publicizing them (called science by press conference")
by claiming a theory predicts something that it does not;
by claiming a theory predicts something that it has not been shown to predict;
by violating Occam's Razor, the heuristic principle of choosing the explanation that requires the fewest additional assumptions when multiple viable explanations are possible; or
by a lack of progress toward additional evidence of its claims.
Pseudoscience is distinguishable from revelation, theology, or spirituality in that it claims to offer insight into the physical world by "scientific" means. Systems of thought that rely upon "divine" or "inspired" knowledge are not considered pseudoscience if they do not claim either to be scientific or to overturn well-established science. There are also bodies of practical knowledge that are not claimed to be scientific. These are also not pseudoscience.
Pseudoscience is also distinguishable from misleading statements in some popular science, where commonly held beliefs are thought to meet the criteria of science, but often don't. The issue is muddled, however, because it is believed that "pop" science blurs the divide between science and pseudoscience among the general public.
The term "pseudoscience" is often used by adherents of fields considered pseudoscientific to criticize their mainstream equivalents. Hence, for instance, supporters of creationism often characterize evolution as a pseudoscience, as do supporters of Dianetics with respect to psychiatry. Such criticisms are, however, generally regarded as fringe viewpoints.
Pseudoscience contrasted with protoscience
Pseudoscience also differs from protoscience. Protoscience is a term sometimes used to describe a hypothesis that has not yet been tested adequately by the scientific method, but which is otherwise consistent with existing science or which, where inconsistent, offers reasonable account of the inconsistency.
Pseudoscience, in contrast, is characteristically lacking in adequate tests or the possibility of them, occasionally untestable in principle, and its supporters are frequently strident in insisting that existing scientific results are wrong. Pseudoscience is often unresponsive to ordinary scientific procedures (for example, peer review, publication in standard journals). In some cases, no one applying scientific methods could disprove a pseudoscientific hypothesis (that is, untestable claims have been made) and failure to test and disprove these claims is often cited as evidence of the truth of the pseudoscience.
The boundaries between pseudoscience, protoscience, and "real" science are often unclear to non-specialist observers. They can even be obscure to experts. Many people have tried to offer objective criteria for the term, with mixed success. Often the term is used simply as a pejorative to express the speaker's low opinion of a given field, regardless of any objective measures.
If the claims of a given pseudoscience can be experimentally tested it may be real science, however odd, astonishing, or intuitively unacceptable. If they cannot be tested, it is likely pseudoscience. If the claims made are inconsistent with existing experimental results or established theory, it is often presumed to be pseudoscience. Conversely, if the claims of any given "science" cannot be experimentally tested it may not be a real science, however obvious or intuitively acceptable.
In such circumstances it may be difficult to distinguish which of two opposing "sciences" are valid; for example, both the proponents and opponents of the Kyoto Protocol on global warming have recruited the help of scientists to endorse contradictory positions, because of differing political goals. This enlistment of science in the service of politics is sometimes called "junk science".
Other examples of modern scientific pursuits that some consider protoscience include both the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI) and Communication with Extraterrestrial Intelligence (CETI) research projects. However, these fields are not considered protoscientific by most scientists; they are genererally considered real science, albeit subjects that may offer only a low probability of revealing significant results. Conversely, proponents of Intelligent design consider their ideas to be protoscience, while many scientists consider them to be pseudoscience.
The difference between these subjects as science and pseudoscience may be seen by these examples: Scientists involved in SETI and CETI do not claim that they know for certain that intelligent extraterrestrials exist, although most consider the possibility likely (see Drake equation). They test their beliefs against available data.
Ultimately, whether something is pseudoscience or not has less to do with the ideas under study than the approach used to study or justify them. Acupuncture, for instance, while it involved a prescientific system, is not inherently pseudoscientific. This is because most of the claims can be tested scientifically so acupuncture can be viewed as a protoscience. Of course, a scientific investigation might fail to support the claims of acupuncture. In the presence of a number of tests that successfully falsify a particular claim, insisting that the claim is still scientifically supported becomes pseudoscience.
Fields often associated with pseudoscience
Below are examples of theories and fields of endeavor which their critics believe are often associated in one way or another with pseudoscience. Their adherents normally disagree with such characterizations:
Acupuncture (the traditional theory behind it)
Alchemy (pre- or proto-scientific rather than pseudoscientific)
Astrology
Biblical scientific foresight
Chakra theory
Characterology
Chiropractic
Clairvoyance
Context speaking budgies
Creation science and its offshoots and many of the "theories" invoked in its defense:
Baraminology
Creation biology
Creationist cosmologies
Flood geology
Intelligent design
Specified complexity
Cryptozoology
Dianetics (The pseudoscience of Scientology.)
Essentialism
Eugenics
Feng Shui
Folk psychiatry
Graphology
Götaland theory
Homeopathy
Hypnosis (to help retrieve "repressed memories")
Lunaception
Megalithic yard and other pseudoscientific metrology
Melanin Theory
Modern geocentrism (see also Flat Earth Society)
Natural Hygiene
Neuro-linguistic programming (NLP)
New Chronology
Novelty Theory (aka "Timewave Zero")
Orgonomy
Palmistry
Parapsychology
Schemes for Perpetual motion
Personology
Phrenology
Physiognomy
Precognition
Pseudoarchaeology
Psychoanalitic theory (See closed circle)
Pyramidology
Scientology
Spiritualism
Technological Singularity
Time Cube (also see Gene Ray)
Explanations of Telekinesis
Explanations of Telepathy
Vedic science
Pseudosciences and medical practices are often quite popular. Medical pseudosciences even sometimes produce perceptions of therapeutic benefit, possibly due to the placebo effect or observer bias. These are usually subjective perceptions, with any objectively measurable physiological effects being of a limited and temporary nature.
Many pseudosciences are associated with the New Age movement, but there is a tendency to improperly associate all "New Age" practices with pseudoscience.
Certain "watchdog" groups, such as CSICOP, have released statements expressing concern about the apparent growing popularity of pseudoscience, especially when it applies to scientific fields that are intended to save people's lives. A number of self-proclaimed alternative medicine treatments have been designated pseudoscience by critics, largely because some of these methods inspire false hope in terminally ill patients, and end up costing large amounts of money without actually providing any real benefit, treatment, or cure for various ailments.
The Baloney Detection Collection
One could easily find a large number of books on the subject of baloney detection,
pseudoscience, and pathological science and deception. A complete bibliography
would fill several pages. Michael Shermer, Robert Park, Carl Sagan, and others have
written books and articles about these subjects. All have produced lists of things
to look for and questions to ask in order to detect bogus claims or even outright
fraud.
What follows is a synthesis of a number of these. All writers will say that no
scheme provides completely foolproof detection of bogus claims; however, if you
poke and prod the claim with the questions that follow, the odds are in your
favor. The questions are in no particular order, so you'll have to mine out the
applicable ones.
1. How is the claim/discovery announced?
A scientific discovery is checked and reviewed before being accepted for
publication in a peer-reviewed journal. If a claim or discovery is announced
by holding a press conference, beware. Such a claim may be unverified - not
checked by an independent investigator. The cold fusion debacle is often cited.
Robert Park's description of this affair in "Voodoo Science" is recommended reading.
Also beware of "discovery" announcements that ask you to subscribe (pay) to
some newsletter.
2. Does this source often make such claims?
If this particular source frequently makes claims that bear no resemblance
to the best current knowledge, beware. There was someone in Dallas who, as
the year 2000 approached, made a series of predictions based on the book of Revelations.
He described how the sky would open up, trumpets would sound, and the
world would end. Obviously, nothing happened.
3. Is anecdotal evidence cited?
Anecdotes, or individual stories, are not scientifically useful. Such a
story suggests only that the individual did so-and-so (assuming no fakery).
Nothing about larger populations can be inferred from it.
Any description of an
invention or product which uses large numbers of anecdotes or testimonials is
suspect. You also must remember that testimonials can be bought; you can pay someone
to do it for you. Also - the Federal Trade Commission will prosecute false
claims, but testimonials are not regulated.
4. Does the source claim that "the establishment is trying to suppress this discovery?"
Such a claim does not provide any evidence that the "discovery" is really valid.
You need to poke these with other questions to find out more.
5. Does the claim fit in with what we know about the world?
Does it fit into the larger context of knowledge? Shermer describes the
claim that the Earth is only 6,000 years old. Accepting that claim requires
that you also concede that everything learned about the Earth and solar system
through astronomy, physics, geology, biology and other sciences is completely wrong.
6. Was the "discovery" made in isolation?
The reality of this world is that someone not trained in the science and
its methods and working alone in a garage is not likely to make any kind of
significant scientific discovery. Such a person making a great "discovery" is
likely to be misinterpreting a known effect. They will likely persist with their
belief in their discovery even after being shown that it is a well-known effect.
7. Has anyone tried to disprove the claim?
It is very important to find out if other investigators have tried to
replicate the work. Toward this end, real scientists will publish complete
information about the work, enough for another competent investigator to attempt
replication. Others will repeat the work and publish the results.
8. Is this source offering a new explanation for observed phenomena, or simply
attacking the existing explanation?
As with claims of suppression, this claim does not offer any evidence that
the discovery is valid. Anyone attacking an existing explanation had better
offer evidence. Absent evidence, all you know is that they do not like the
existing explanation, for whatever reason.
9. Does the source claim that "this knowledge has been around for so long
it must be good?"
A lot of interesting "discoveries" were made a long time ago. These include
such gems as "the Earth is flat", "fire is a result of the phlogiston escaping
from the burning material", and "the primary components of everything are Earth,
air, fire and water." That they have been around a long time doesn't make
them right. Again, what is the evidence?
10. Is the observed effect very small and accompanied by lack of success in
increasing it?
Along this line, is the experiment a multi-trial statistical one or a direct
measurement? Park's description of mind-over-matter experiments is recommended.
Although balances capable of measuring micro-gram (very tiny) forces exist,
mind-over-matter experiments use statistical trials, possibly because no claimant has
ever been able to move a micro-balance with thoughts. The small effect observed
in statistical trials is likely due to some small systemic bias in the experiment
itself. The polywater affair is an example of a small effect that could not
be increased.
11. Does the evidence for the "discovery" not get any better with time?
See number 10 above. If the observed affect is really a tiny bias in the
experiment, nothing the investigator can do will increase the effect. Another
thing to check is the results of better experiments. If, as the experimental
methods improve, the observed effect gets smaller, it is likely that a perfect
experiment will show no effect at all.
12. What does the bulk of evidence point to - the new claim or something else?
Is the source focusing on one small thing and ignoring a huge base of
accumulated evidence that points to something else? Be sure to look at the
claim in the context of current knowledge.
13. What kind of reasoning has been used?
Beware of "Post hoc, ergo propter hoc" thinking; this implies confusion
about causation. This latin adage translates as "after this, therefore because
of this." If A happened then B happened, then obviously A caused B. This is a
very bad assumption. A claim that A caused B must be accompanied by credible
evidence showing how A caused B. To put it simply, correlation does not mean
causation.
Also beware of such things as questionable techniques (like hypnotic regression),
anecdotal evidence (see 3 above), conspiracy theories (like government
cover-ups), poor quality evidence (low-resolution photos) and simple misperceptions.
14. Does the new claim offers a new explanation for something, does it
account for as many phenomena as the old one did?
Einstein's relativity explained more phenomena than did Newtonian mechanics.
At velocities much less than the velocity of light, relativity reduces to
Newtonian mechanics.
15. Is there any indication that the source's personal beliefs and biases are
driving the conclusions?
Has contradictory evidence been ignored or pushed aside? It is necessary
to consider all the evidence, not just the favorable bits. The process of
science tends to sort this out.
16. Is it possible to test the claim?
Obviously, a statement that "God did it" cannot be tested in any way. Such
a claim is an untestable construct. Explanations that do not make any
testable predictions are of no use. They do not add to knowledge.
17. Is a chain of evidence (links) offered?
If chain of evidentiary links for a claim is presented, every link must
be solid. A proposed chain of evidence fails completely if even one link fails.
If someone claims that A causes B, B causes C, C causes D, and D causes E,
they had better be prepared to demonstrate EVERY link. If, for example,
all links are proven except that C causes D, which cannot be in any way
demonstrated, then there is no proof that A results in E.
18. In extreme cases, such as claims about UFOs, can hoax be confidently
ruled out?
Evidence for "flying saucers" is usually photographic. Modern image processing
technology is so good that it is no longer possible to reliably detect a hoax
photograph by examining it. A claim that a photograph has "passed all
photographic
analyses" may mean nothing more than that the hoax is very well done.
The 1967 Patterson film of a Bigfoot has long been considered the best evidence
for the existence of that creature. The film was widely thought to be genuine
until an investigator named Greg Long did several years work interviewing
everyone in the area who knew anything about Roger Patterson. What Long
turned up was evidence that was more than sufficient to show that the famous
film is a hoax. Long even talked to the costume manufacturer who sold
Patterson the gorilla suit!
If hoax cannot be ruled out, there remains a small probability that the evidence
is fake.
19. Would a claimed invention violate the laws of thermodynamics?
Be aware of the laws of thermodynamics. The universe operates according
to a set of physical laws that we understand reasonably well. Those laws govern
what can and cannot be done. No amount of cleverness or piety will allow anyone
to violate those laws.
The First Law of Thermodynamics says, simply, that "you can't win."
Energy is conserved; it is not magically created. Always remember the old phrase "
Non gratuitum prandium", which means "no free lunch." No thermal energy can be
extracted from a single source - a heat flow from hot to cold is required.
The Second Law of Thermodynamics says "you can't even break even." Any
energy conversion process has losses - the output energy will be less than the
input. The difference is wasted and contributes to increasing the entropy of the
universe. No one has ever found a way to get around this.
20. Is the claim/discovery really spectacular?
Scientists will tell you that "extraordinary claims require extraordinary
evidence." They mean exactly that. If the claim is that life has been found
on Mars or that someone has found a way to eliminate aging, really extraordinary
evidence will be required to demonstrate it. A vague observation or a few
anecdotes will not do the job.
21. Beware of special pleadings.
Be especially wary of any claim or excuse that the claimed effect cannot be
measured for some reason. It may be that "the presence of a skeptic contaminates
the effect", or "attempting to measure the effect destroys it", or "bad vibrations
interfered", or something like that. An "effect" that cannot be measured
likely does not exist.
22. If the effect is measured from a sample, how was the sample obtained?
Obtaining a proper random sample for a statistical measurement is more
difficult than most people realize. There are many problems that can occur with
sampling, problems that can seriously bias the results.
For example, suppose you want to take a poll about something and you want
a random sample of the population of your city. How to do it? You might
think of randomly choosing names from the phone directory - but that will
exclude all people who either have no phone or have unlisted numbers.
Try going downtown and randomly picking people who pass by. That will exclude
all people who do not go downtown. Getting a real random sample is not easy.
23. Beware of "It can't be, so it isn't" thinking.
In the Cottingley Fairies incident, in 1917, two young girls took photographs
which supposedly showed fairies cavorting with them in the woods. The two
girls who photographed the fairies were considered incapable of perpetrating
such a hoax, and thus followed the conclusion that they had not. The photos
were therefore fawned over as genuine pictures of fairies. Truth was that the girls
had indeed cut the "fairies" out of paper and photographed them in a prank
which got out of hand when others saw the photos. This was not figured
out until 1978.
24. Look at spelling and grammar.
When reading any web site, flyer, or anything else, be aware of how well
the stuff is written. A web site or printed item that is filled with
misspellings and bad grammar is highly suspect.
A number of excellent books on the subject of pseudo-science exist. Here are
some good ones. Please remember that there are many more. The book on
hoaxes is included because it is a good collection of historical (and
hysterical) hoaxes.
Park, Robert L., "Voodoo Science", Oxford University Press 2000
ISBN 0-19-513515-6.
Sagan, Carl, "The Demon-Haunted World", Random House 1996.
ISBN 0-394-53512-X
Shermer, Michael, "Why People Believe Weird Things", Freeman 1997
ISBN 0-7167-3387-0
Carey, Stephen S., "A Beginner's Guide to Scientific method",
Wadsworth 1998 ISBN 0-534-52843-0
Randi, James, "Flim-Flam", Prometheus 1988 ISBN 0-87975-198-3
Schick, T. & Vaughn, L., "How to Think About Weird Things: Critical
Thinking for a New Age", McGraw-Hill 2002. ISBN 0-7674-2048-9
Boese, Alex, "The Museum of Hoaxes", Dutton 2002. ISBN 0-525-94678-0